By Jeconais
Reviews
Milarqui posted a comment on Thursday 5th April 2007 11:09am
Damn! This story was one of the funniest[\italic] I've ever read! First time I heard about your story, I didn't read it, because I thought - wrongly - that this story wouldn't be like this, but after a recommendation from somebody I won't mention - mainly because I don't remember whom - I decided to read it. I swear I've never read something as funny as this story, and the idea behind the Mmails what fantastic! If only J.K. had thought of that...
Please, search my work "Harry Poter and the Unexpected Visitor" in SIYE and leave your impressions.
Thank you for your story.
Milarqui.
P.D: I love Harry/Ginny!!!![\bold]
Dags posted a comment on Friday 30th March 2007 4:08pm
I was just wondering, now that you've 'finished' the story....you never added in the Sadie Hawkins dance, maybe that could be an epilouge, as I am looking forward to seeing Ginny's dress and weather Blaise/Luna won the emphasising contest
Mariposa posted a comment on Thursday 29th March 2007 5:28am
Thank you for finally finishing IT! It was a great ride!
in-fanficauthors posted a comment on Wednesday 28th March 2007 11:50am
A long haul, but a nice one. If you don't want to write a H/G one, that doesn't mean you shouldn't write!
Great job.
Erica Douglas posted a comment on Tuesday 27th March 2007 7:45pm
Wow. I'll come back later and revise this, if I can think of more coherent praise.
Thank you!
Nights_Silhouette posted a comment on Monday 26th March 2007 5:03pm
A great chapter, a great story. Keep writing.
elizabeth d posted a comment on Sunday 25th March 2007 5:46am
Thanks for a great story. I LOVED the way you used the mmails to flesh out the secondary characters in addition to moving the plot along. Very clever. I read this one at my husband's recommendation (Aaran St. V). He was right...it was a blast!
Aeryn posted a comment on Friday 23rd March 2007 8:05am
A fantastic end to an absolutely wonderful story. Thank you for sharing it with the fandom and the world - I think this story has earned a place as my all-time favourite HP fanfic. Congratulations on a job very well done!
- Aeryn
Rogue15us posted a comment on Tuesday 20th March 2007 11:14pm
I cannot say how much I have loved this story since it first came out. I can't even think of enough things to say of how good it is. I have had the last two chapters in my inbox since they came out just because I did not have the time to enjoy it.
So after all that I just wanted to say Thanks for writing it. It gave me something enjoyable to read that is kinda lighthearted for a long while now and sometimes you just need something like that.
The only thing that sort of confused me was torwards the end when you said how many aurors there were. With a population of One Million they should of had quite a few more then One Hundred odd Aurors. More like a couple of thousand.
But then again if they had that many the story might not be possible. So either way still enjoyable.
I have to say that I did like how Riddle was taken care of it the end. Very Anti-Climatic. Which is the way it should be in any properly planned and executed War.
Here's to looking forward to more of Wild Horses and Hope.
Rogue
williams posted a comment on Tuesday 20th March 2007 2:36pm
I've been lurking around your site waiting for you to finish this story (I do a lot of systems analysis and project planning so I spend up to six hours in my office reading or sleeping) because I hate being forced to stop reading a story and wait for updates. I'm an only child, I'm whiny like that.
This is an incredibly, amazing, believable view of fantasy. It's like reading Asimov or Clarke writing science fiction - yes, it's grounded in fact/canon - it's totally within character, or rather, based on established fact; a layered fantasy on fantasy. Let me check under my tea cozy for some more hyperbolic superlatives.
The plot is outstanding; the character canonizations are outstanding - you handle their language appropriately - for example; Ron's attitude was masterful and completely within character; Dumbledore's "hands off" policy is completely based in fact/canon; the inter-character interactions are outstanding.
I burst out laughing in my office reading the YMCA scene. I had a tear in my eye when Ginny was comforting Harry in the Great Hall after showing Snape his childhood - if you repeat that to anyone I'll deny it.
I tip my hat in respect as I jauntily head off to drink beers and play darts. I'm halfway through Chapter Eight and fully expect there will be no systems analyzed nor projects planned tomorrow.
Victor1 posted a comment on Thursday 15th March 2007 6:35pm
you are an amazing writer.
i've been following you since you first wrote this story!
and man, the years have gone by hahaha
its been an AMAZING journey, and i'm SO THANKFUL that it was this good.
thank you for the experience it was fantastic.
don't stop writing, you have a gift.
Trebond posted a comment on Tuesday 13th March 2007 9:25pm
THANKS!!!!
For a total mega super nice brilliant story!
I did read some of this story for about half a year ago, and i was prety sad that it wasnt finish. But it have been all the waiting time worthy. I have been reading for about 8-9 hours strait right now, and its about 6.20 in the morning, but again it have been the hole ting and time worthy.
Love it all, I realy cant find any flaws in this story. It got the right mix of Harry-overpowered, and the problems he got to fix, and the right amound of love etc.
And a great way the final battel did end. In most storyes Harry just get the army to defend the Dark Tosser and his men. But here HJP's army is totaly in overpower and is huge number. But its great that its got a reason.
About the Mmail: GREAT great great idéar!!
Nearly wish there was a Epilogue for this story, to tell how it did go for the chars in the next few days/weeks/mounths or years. :)
Again: Thanks!
Kind Regards
Trebon ..
Louis IX posted a comment on Tuesday 13th March 2007 1:52pm
I'm happy with all the parts. This was a wonderful story. Thanks for taking the time to finish it.
Trav posted a comment on Sunday 11th March 2007 11:26pm
A fitting end to a monumental Epic, good sir. Inspirational and entertaining as any novel on the market. I can only hope to be a shadow of the kind of excellence you display in my own works.
And so, I say to thee, Bravo and well done.
Claire_D posted a comment on Sunday 11th March 2007 5:30am
Wow what an ending. I love it :D congrats on finishing such a long fic
nurray posted a comment on Saturday 10th March 2007 12:54pm
Congratulations, you have finished it.
It was well worth the wait. Thankyou for a very enjoyable story.
I wonder when the twins will find out that they were pranked by Hermione?
Bethany posted a comment on Saturday 10th March 2007 10:30am
Once again…perfect. Thank you for sharing your talents with us lowly readers. I’m sad it is over, but you did such a wonderful job with ending the story. I actually started crying I was laughing so hard at the "Your mother was a hamster and your father smelt of elderberries". So perfect.
Thank you again, I enjoyed it immensely. Congratulations on a job well done!
Jianne posted a comment on Friday 9th March 2007 9:30pm
Thank you. I have been following this story for a few years and I just wanted you to know that I absolutely loved this story from start to finish. I laughed, I cried, I cheered and I giggled. I kept the story URL in my favourites and would check back periodically always with hope, so you can only imagine how elated I was to find that you had picked up the story again. What a wild ride!
gratefully
Jianne
Jia
The Great Phoenix posted a comment on Friday 9th March 2007 6:26pm
P.S. - Forgot to mention this earlier, nut do you happen to actually know what exactly Sirius told Harry? Or why the window for reviews is so much narrower when it's being typed than when it's viewed, so that it looks like a lot more has been typed than there actually has when the person is typing it?
Jonny posted a comment on Thursday 5th April 2007 12:01pm